Reviewed by the Penny Time editorial team

Part of our Saving hub.

Trump Account vs 529 vs Roth IRA vs UTMA: Which One Should You Open?

Quick answer: If your baby was born 2025 to 2028, open a Trump Account now to grab the free $1,000. If college is your goal, also open a 529. If your kid has a real job (even babysitting that you report), also open a Roth IRA. You can have all three. Skip the UTMA/UGMA unless you have a specific non-college, non-retirement reason.

As of July 4, 2026, every eligible newborn in the U.S. can get a free $1,000 from the government in a new kind of investment account called a Trump Account, once you elect your child. Mom and dad can add more on top. It is the biggest new way to save for kids in a generation.

But it is not the only one. And honestly, for most families, it should sit next to two other accounts that have been around for a while. Here is the plain-English breakdown of all three, plus the custodial account (UTMA/UGMA) they all get compared to, so you can pick the right one without needing a finance degree.

The three accounts in plain English

Trump Account: free money from the government, grows for the long haul

The new one. Babies born January 2025 through December 2028 get a $1,000 deposit from Treasury once you elect them, and accounts opened July 4, 2026. After that, families can add up to $5,000 per year combined. If your employer offers a program, up to $2,500 of that $5,000 can come from them; it counts toward the cap, not on top of it. The $1,000 government seed does not count against the $5,000.

The money has to sit in low-cost index funds (basically: a slice of the whole U.S. stock market). You cannot pick individual stocks or fancy funds. That is on purpose, so families do not lose the seed money on bad bets.

Your kid takes control at age 18. They can keep the money invested or take some out (but if they pull it before age 59.5, they pay tax on it plus a 10% penalty, same as a regular retirement account).

One-line summary: Free money to grow for a long time, light tax break, kid takes the wheel at 18.

529 Plan: built for college, biggest tax break if you use it for school

Around since 1996. You put after-tax money in, it grows without being taxed each year, and when you take it out for school costs (tuition, room and board, books, even up to $10,000 of K-12), you pay zero tax on the growth.

Most states also give you a state income tax break on what you put in each year. That is real money in your pocket every April.

You can put in a lot. Most states cap it between $235,000 and $600,000 in total. You stay in control even after your kid grows up.

The catch: if you take the money out and use it for something other than school, you pay tax on the growth plus a 10% penalty. So this is the wrong account if your kid skips college.

One-line summary: The college account. Best tax break of any kid-savings option, but the money is meant for school.

Roth IRA for Kids: only works if your kid has a real job

This one is a sleeper. If your kid earns money from a real job (with a paycheck, or self-employment they report), they can put it in a Roth IRA. The money grows tax-free forever, and they can take out what they put in at any time without penalty.

The catch: they need earned income. A 4-year-old cannot have a Roth IRA. A 14-year-old with a summer job can.

Limit in 2026: $7,500 per year, or their total earned income, whichever is less. So if your kid earns $500 babysitting all summer, they can put up to $500 into a Roth IRA.

Why it is a sleeper: $500 at age 14, growing at 7% a year until age 65, becomes about $16,000. All tax-free. From one summer of babysitting.

One-line summary: The retirement head-start. Only works if your kid earns money. Best tax break in the long run.

Side by side: the cheat sheet

Trump Account vs custodial account (UTMA/UGMA)

This is the comparison most parents get stuck on, because a custodial account is the one that has been around forever and it is what your own parents probably would have used. A UTMA or UGMA is the plain wrapper: you open an investment account in your kid's name, you manage it, and the money is legally theirs from the moment it goes in. No special tax status, no rules about what it gets spent on.

Here is how the two actually differ once you get past the paperwork.

• Getting money in. The Trump Account caps you at $5,000 a year, and any money your employer chips in counts toward that $5,000 rather than sitting on top of it. A custodial account has no annual cap at all. You only bump into the gift-tax rules, which let any one person give $19,000 a year before a form is involved. So if you are trying to move a large sum, the custodial account is the one with room.
• Tax. The Trump Account lets everything grow untaxed and you settle up when the money comes out. A custodial account is taxed as you go: the first $1,350 your kid earns in interest and dividends each year is tax-free, the next $1,350 gets taxed at their rate, and past $2,700 it is taxed at yours. That last layer is the kiddie tax, and it is the reason a big custodial account is less of a bargain than it looks.
• When your kid takes over. Both hand control to your kid, but the custodial handoff is the harder one. UTMA accounts transfer at 21 in most states, UGMA at 18, and it is permanent and irreversible. You cannot claw the money back or attach conditions to it. Plenty of parents are fine with that. Plenty are not, and it is worth deciding which you are before you fund one.
• College aid. A custodial account belongs to your kid, so financial aid formulas count it as a student asset and expect a much bigger slice of it to go toward the bill than they would from an account in your name. If college is anywhere in the plan, this alone is usually the tiebreaker.

Who each one actually fits. Take the Trump Account first if your kid qualifies for the seed, because $1,000 of free money beats any tax argument. Reach for a custodial account when you have a specific reason the other three cannot handle: a grandparent wants to gift more than the Trump Account cap allows, or the money is earmarked for something that is not college and not retirement, like a first car or a gap year. For most families the custodial account is the fourth choice, not the first.

Which one (or which combo) should you actually open?

Most families do not have to pick just one. The accounts are not in competition. Here is the order that works for almost everyone:

1. If your kid qualifies for the $1,000 Trump Account seed, take it. No-brainer. It is free money. It will be worth about $10,000 by their 18th birthday if you do nothing else, just from sitting in the market.
2. If college is the goal, put your college dollars in a 529. Better tax break than the Trump Account, plus most states throw in their own break. Use the savings goal calculator to work out what you need to put away each week to hit your target.
3. The summer your kid earns their first $100 from a job, open a Roth IRA. The amounts are small, but starting at 14 instead of 24 is the difference between "comfortable retirement" and "very comfortable retirement." See the first jobs for teens guide for what counts.
4. Skip the UTMA/UGMA unless you have a specific reason. No tax break, no free seed, and your kid takes full control at 18 to do whatever they want with it. The other three accounts beat it on every dimension except total flexibility.

How to talk to your kid about it

Money accounts are one of those topics that feel grown-up to kids, which is exactly why they are fun to explain. Use the moment to plant the idea that money can work for you while you sleep. Here is the language by age.

Ages 5 to 7: "Money that babysits more money"

Do not name the accounts. Focus on the magic.

Try this: "If I give you $1 today, you have $1. But if we put that $1 in a special savings box that grows a tiny bit on its own, in a few years you have $2. The grown-up word is interest. It is the money that babysits more money for you while you wait."

For Trump Account specifically: "The government is giving every new baby $1,000 to put in a savings box that grows for a long time. By the time you can drive, it will be worth way more than $1,000."

Ages 8 to 12: "Different boxes for different reasons"

Now you can introduce the idea of multiple accounts.

Try this: "Grown-ups have different savings boxes for different reasons. One is just for college (a 529). One is for when they stop working a long time from now (a Roth IRA). And there is a new one from the government for kids born around now (a Trump Account). The rules are different for each box, but they all do the same trick: the longer the money stays in, the more it grows."

Show them the math. The Rule of 72 calculator takes one number (your growth rate) and tells you how long until your money doubles. At 7% per year, money doubles every 10.3 years. So $1,000 at age 0 turns into $2,000 at 10, $4,000 at 20, $8,000 at 30. Magic, but it is math.

Ages 13+: "This is where your future money comes from"

Now they can handle the real account differences.

Try this: "When you get your first real job, you can open something called a Roth IRA. Whatever you put in, you can take out later (after age 59.5) and never pay tax on what it grew into. If you put $1,000 in this summer when you are 14, and it grows at 7% a year, you will have over $30,000 by retirement. From one summer."

If they have a paystub already, walk through it together. The teen paycheck calculator shows the gross vs net split. The net pay is what counts as earned income for a Roth IRA.

Five questions to ask your kid this week

1. "If you got $1,000 today and could not spend it for 18 years, what would you do with it?"
2. "Why do you think the government wants every new baby to have a savings account?"
3. "What is the difference between saving for next week and saving for 20 years from now?"
4. "Pick one: more money today, or twice as much money in 10 years?"
5. "What is something a grown-up version of you might want? Should we start saving for it now?"

How to open a Trump Account now that they are live

Accounts opened July 4, 2026. To claim the $1,000 seed, sign in (or create an account) at irs.gov/trumpaccounts with ID.me, then complete and submit IRS Form 4547 to elect your child. You will need your child's Social Security number, date of birth, and address. Once the election is processed, the deposit lands and you can add up to $5,000 a year on top. Our Trump Account explainer walks through the full process step by step, and the Trump Account calculator shows what the seed grows into by age 18.

Sources

• IRS: Trump Accounts
• Treasury/IRS: Trump Accounts Guidance (Notice on upcoming regulations)
• Fidelity: Trump Accounts vs 529s, UTMA/UGMAs, and Roth IRAs
• Vanguard: What to know about new Trump Accounts for kids
• Chase: Trump Accounts for Kids, Key Rules
• Charles Schwab: What to Know About Trump Accounts
• Bankrate: Trump Accounts vs 529s and custodial Roth IRAs

Raise kids who understand how money works

Download Penny Time

No credit card. No ads. No strings.

Put this into practice this week

Penny Time turns allowance into a real balance your child tracks on their own device, with your approval on every cash-out. Free for the whole family.